Amazon Prime Video’s The Girlfriend (2025) gripped audiences with its dark psychological thriller plot and dual-perspective storytelling. The finale left fans shocked as Daniel, under Cherry’s influence, drowned his mother, Laura. But the ending raised more questions than answers — sparking speculation about a potential Season 2.
Here’s a breakdown of fan theories, cast return possibilities, and storyline directions if the thriller continues.
Could Laura Return in Season 2?
Laura’s drowning was the most heartbreaking twist of Season 1. But fans aren’t convinced it’s the end of Robin Wright’s character.
- Could flashbacks or dual timelines bring her back?
- Was her death staged by Cherry as part of a bigger scheme?
- Or will Wright return only behind the camera, directing future episodes?
Cherry’s Next Move
Cherry (Olivia Cooke) remains the series’ biggest mystery. Is she a manipulative con artist who destroyed a family, or a misunderstood young woman fighting back against Laura’s control?
- Season 2 could explore her past, revealing hidden motives.
- A fresh storyline might show Cherry starting over with a new target, continuing the cycle.
Daniel’s Guilt Spiral
Daniel killed his own mother — but how long can he live with it?
- One theory suggests Daniel may unravel, exposing Cherry.
- Others think he will double down, becoming Cherry’s partner in crime in a darker Season 2.
Will Someone Investigate Laura’s Death?
The finale leaves plenty of room for outside characters to step in. A suspicious friend, neighbor, or even a detective could investigate Laura’s “accident,” turning Season 2 into a tense cat-and-mouse thriller.
Anthology Possibility
Some fans believe The Girlfriend could take an anthology route, introducing a brand-new toxic relationship story under the same title. This approach would mirror The Girlfriend Experience and keep the concept fresh while closing Laura and Cherry’s chapter.
Who Was the Real Villain?
The heart of the series is its ambiguity:
- Was Laura a paranoid, overbearing mother?
- Or was Cherry a dangerous manipulator who pulled Daniel’s strings?
This unresolved question makes a follow-up season highly tempting for both creators and viewers.
Final Thoughts
While Amazon has not officially confirmed The Girlfriend Season 2, the ending of Season 1 was far too ambiguous to ignore. With fan theories flooding social media, the appetite for a continuation is clear.
Whether as a direct sequel following Cherry and Daniel’s aftermath, or as an anthology-style reboot with a new toxic love story, The Girlfriend has all the ingredients for another binge-worthy season.